Which Country is the Most Generous on Pokémon Wonder Trade?

For those not in the know Pokémon is a game about collecting as many of digital monsters as you can. Wonder Trade allows you to put up a Pokémon you have caught and Nintendo will randomly find another person currently using Wonder Trade and swap your two Pokémon around, the interesting thing is you don't know what you are going to get, and your Pokémon is gone for good, you can't get it back once the trade has been finished. You may find you put in your fairly valuable Pokémon only to be given a rubbish pidgin in return.

Doing a Pokemon Wonder Trade

Before this happens you do get to see the player name of the person about to get your Pokémon and what country they are from, after doing many hundreds of trades I found myself guessing what I was about to get just from the location of the other player. Often I was wrong but it got me wondering if there was a small trend for countries to be more or less stingy on what they give the other player.

Person from Pokemon Wonder Trade

It's worth saying there is absolutely no advantage to giving away a valuable Pokémon, you are just connected with a random person and they will get whatever you give them. So this led me to ponder if countries with higher average incomes would be more generous with what they gave away? Would a richer country give more valuable Pokémon to a random person they don't know? Or are poor countries better at sharing their wealth?


Ok, so I’ve now done 1000 Wonder Trades on Pokémon Sun/Moon. It’s taken about 50 hours over 60 days to do them all. I recorded every country I got a trade from and gave the Pokémon they sent a score. This is how I scored each trade:


How I Scored Each Pokémon:

Valueless:
Common:
Good:
Rare:
Very Rare:
Exceedingly Valuable:
- Found in the first 2 hours of the game.
- Found after the start of the game.
- Only one obtainable in this game.
- Not in this. game.
- Starter.
- Needed to be evolved.
- Version exclusive.


- Only one obtainable in another game.
- Legendary in this game.
- Starter from another game.
- Shiny.
- Legendary from another game.
- Shiny from another game.
- Shiny Pokemon you can only get one of.
- Shiny legendary.
- Event only.
Most popular Pokemon found in this category:
magikarp Wonder Trade
Magikarp
Most popular Pokemon found in this category: mimikyu Wonder Trade
Mimikyu
Most popular Pokemon found in this category: rowlet Wonder Trade
Rowlet
Most popular Pokemon found in this category: charmander Wonder Trade
Charmander
Most popular Pokemon found in this category: ho-oh Wonder Trade
Ho-Oh
Most popular Pokemon found in this category: rayquaza Wonder Trade
Rayquaza

Percentage of total:
54%
Percentage of total:
22%
Percentage of total:
16%
Percentage of total:
6%
Percentage of total:
<1%
Percentage of total:
<1%
Worth 0 point
Worth 1 point
Worth 2 point
Worth 3 point
Worth 4 point
Worth 5 point



To keep it fair I made sure I did trades at all times of the day to try and capture as many countries as possible. Most of the time I would put up a starter Pokémon of my own from the older games. so if you got a starter from Wonder Trade with a funny name it might have been from me.

I don't know how prevalent hacked Pokémon are and this could skew the results (richer or poorer countries being more likely to use those tools). I did get an excessive amount of shiny Pokémon and I can't believe those are legitimately being given away in that quantity.

Score of Each Country:

Country name Best Gift Worst Gift Most Common Trade Average Score Number of trades Ranking
Norway
3
Bulbasaur
0
Magnemite
Multiple 1.37 8 271st
Netherlands
3
Torchic
0
Caterpie
Multiple 1.26 15 262nd
Finland
3
Yamask
0
Spearow
Multiple 1.25 4 253rd
Australia
5
Hoopa
0
Magnemite
0
Magnemite
1.22 22 244th
Ireland
2
Snubbull
0
Magikarp
Multiple 1.2 5 235th
Belgium
2
Dewpider
0
Pikipek
Multiple 1.12 8 226th
Canada
3
Charmander
0
Magikarp
0
Pikipek
1 13 217th
Germany
5
Dialga (Shiny)
0
Spearow
1
Mimikyu
0.86 66 208th (joint)
Japan
3
Bulbasaur
0
Magikarp
0
Magikarp
0.86 314 198th (joint)
Switzerland
2
Scraggy
0
Wingull
Multiple 0.83 6 1810th
USA
5
Arceus (Shiny)
0
Pikipek
0
Zubat
0.76 219 1711th
Spain
3
Charmander
0
Ralts
Multiple 0.7 65 1612th
UK
3
Charmander
0
Yungoos
0
Yungoos
0.68 47 1513th
Austria
2
Timburr
0
Magikarp
0
Magikarp
0.66 6 1414th (joint)
South Africa
2
Rowlet
0
Fletchling
Multiple 0.66 3 1314th (joint)
Italy
3
Bulbasaur
0
Magikarp
0
Grimer
0.61 21 1216th
Anguilla
1
Geodude
0
Yungoos
Multiple 0.6 5 1117th (joint)
Sweden
3
Tirtouga
0
Yungoos
Multiple 0.6 5 1017th (joint)
South Korea
3
Nidoqueen
0
Magikarp
0
Wingull
0.59 27 0919th
Mexico
2
Golett
0
Abra
Multiple 0.53 13 0820th
France
4
Charizard
0
Spearow
0
Spearow
0.5 80 0721st
Brazil
2
Cottonee
0
Caterpie
Multiple 0.37 8 0622nd
New Zealand
1
Tauros
0
Crabrawler
Multiple 0.33 3 0523rd
Poland
1
Ditto
0
Rattata
Multiple 0.2 5 0424th
Portugal
1
Ditto
0
Grimer
Multiple 0.12 3 0325th
Taiwan
0
Abra
0
Abra
Multiple 0 3 0226th (joint)
Russia
0
Magikarp
0
Magnemite
Multiple 0 3 0126th (joint)
TOTAL 5
Arceus (Shiny)
0
Magnemite
Multiple 0.77 977     

- Excludes countries that did less than 3 trades.
- Excludes the 3 times I forgot to record the country.



Trades for each country:

Let’s have a look at the amount of trades I got for each country, because obviously the more trades I got from a place the more accurate the result will be. You can already see some of the low scoring countries had the least trades because they were not given the time to get some of these rarer trades that would bring up their score, and I accept that, however it’s still fun to carry on and see the results.

number of wonder trades by country
My Stats:
How Long it Took (hours):50
How Long it Took (days):60
Most Common Trade:Magikarp
Total Trades:1000
Number of Shiny Pokémon:8
Number of Valueless Pokémon:545
Number of Common Pokémon:222
Number of Good Pokémon:165
Number of Rare Pokémon:57
Number of Very Rare Pokémon:7
Number of Valuable Pokémon:4

I am aware its pretty ruthless to rate countries by their average income, but also its really brutal rating the generosity on a very small number of trades.

I had a perception that trades at around midnight GMT were the worst, I didn't let this change when I did trades and just spread them out when I could, but I once got 4 Magikarp's in a row which is about as lucky as rolling the same number 3 times on a roulette wheel.



Score of Country vs Wealth of Country:
Pokemon trades Score of Country vs Wealth of Country

It does look to me that the general trend of this graph shows that a countries wealth matches the score they got for their Wonder Trades, there are loads of reasons why this graph could be wrong or there are other factors impacting it. but there does seem to be a correlation to me.

Some of the trades I've got:

A few months before I thought about recording my trades I got a shiny Ditto with maxed out evs, while Ditto itself isn't rare this has been a crazy valuable Pokémon for me as it allows me to breed other Pokémon. I got this before I started recording the country, but whoever you are I thank you because this has totally changed how I play the game. This is the most valuable thing I received because it took a lot of work from the other person to make.


I also got some trades with names that made me laugh, here are a few of them.

Here are the number of time I got each Pokémon and what score I thought they were worth:
Pokémon Number Value
Magikarp590
Pikipek350
Magnemite310
Wingull260
Eevee230
Rattata210
Yungoos200
Zubat180
Abra170
Charmander173
Spearow170
Mimikyu161
Caterpie160
Cutiefly140
Rockruff130
Crabrawler120
Vulpix121
Lillipup120
Salandit120
Ralts120
Meowth110
Grimer110
Rowlet112
Gible112
Metapod100
Slowpoke100
Litten92
Diglett90
Gastly90
Ledyba80
Exeggcute81
Wishiwashi80
Skarmory81
Poliwag80
Pichu81
Gumshoos70
Froakie73
Trumbeak71
Raticate70
Fearow71
Stufful71
Makuhita70
Finneon70
Fletchling70
Bagon60
Torkoal61
Scyther61
Cubone61
Snorunt61
Psyduck60
Popplio62
Growlithe60
Bounsweet51
Mareanie51
Dratini51
Torchic53
Machop50
Carbink51
Riolu51
Wimpod51
Mudbray50
Staryu40
Golduck41
Bulbasaur43
Smeargle40
Pelipper40
Beldum41
Minior41
Geodude41
Grubbin40
Shellder41
Spinarak42
Trapinch41
Fomantis40
Pyukumuku41
Drifloon42
Fletchinder40
Honedge42
Larvitar32
Dugtrio31
Feebas30
Tentacool30
Sandile31
Snivy33
Togedemaru31
Roggenrola30
Porygon32
Surskit32
Pancham31
Ariados32
Cyndaquil33
Pinsir31
Comfey31
Jangmo-o31
Emolga31
Lycanroc32
Snubbull32
Phantump21
Nosepass20
Mudkip22
Ribombee21
Ho-oh24
Hippopotas22
Drampa22
Sandshrew22
Charjabug21
Klefki21
Bellsprout22
Gigalith22
Sandygast21
Shellos22
Marill22
Poliwhirl22
Dewpider22
Morelull22
Granbull21
Gastrodon21
Carvanha22
Araquanid22
Gyarados21
Oricorio20
Piplup23
Absol21
Ferroseed22
Hypno21
Chimchar23
Larvesta22
Bruxish21
Munchlax21
Buneary22
Igglybuff22
Togepi22
Rufflet22
Ditto21
Pikachu21
Fennekin23
Oranguru22
Vullaby22
Axew22
Herdier12
Wailord (Shiny!)13
Squirtle13
Timburr12
Wooper12
Tangela12
Golett12
Turtonator12
Budew12
Mawile12
Pineco12
Wailmer11
Yanma12
Litwick12
Mandibuzz12
Boldore11
Nidoran f12
Tauros11
Conkeldurr12
Talonflame12
Trubbish11
Pachirisu12
Krabby12
Rayquaza (Shiny!)15
Phione13
Stunky12
Tapu Bulu13
Dialga (Shiny!)15
Xurkitree13
Venonat12
Gligar12
Barboach10
Venipede12
Butterfree10
Dhelmise11
Paras12
Delibird11
Glameow12
Tirtouga13
Clauncher12
Frogadier13
Trevenant12
Toucannon12
Yamask13
Gothita12
Roselia12
Buizel12
Hariyama11
Swablu12
Persian12
Sableye11
Sneasel11
Duskull12
Cleffa12
Mankey11
Golbat11
Jolteon12
Skorupi12
Snorlax12
Scraggy12
Elekid11
Marowak12
Dartrix12
Chinchou11
Ledian11
Shroomish12
Exeggutor11
Deino12
Cottonee12
Drifblim12
Chikorita13
Zigzagoon12
Aerodactyl12
Stoutland12
Kartana13
Arceus (Shiny!)15
Audino12
Goldeen11
Charizard14
Dragonite (Shiny!)14
Teddiursa12
Hoopa15
Hitmonlee (Shiny!)14
Magcargo (Shiny!)14
Shuppet12
Eelektross13
Vikavolt12
Sawsbuck (Shiny!)14
Plusle12
Nidoqueen13
Passimian12
Stunfisk12
download full raw data

If you disagree with how I rated each Pokémon or just want to have a play around I think it would be fun to download my raw data and have a play for yourself. You could change the values I gave for each trade and see if that impacts the final results.




Pokemon
By David Strachan